3939 Bay Shore Drive, Sturgeon Bay

Recently renovated 3 bed/3.5 bath Bay Shore retreat set on over three acres of private, wooded landscape. A forested drive welcomes you to this contemporary waterfront home, surrounded by nature and offering a private backyard pond and foot path to 130 feet of sandy beach frontage.

The main level features a spacious primary en suite with large walk in closet, while the upper level includes two additional bedrooms and a full bath, providing comfortable separation of space. A finished walk-out lower level adds versatility with LVP flooring and a full bath, ideal for guests, entertaining, or extended living space.

Extensive updates include all new hardwood flooring, a fully renovated kitchen with added pantry and new appliances, highlighted by a downdraft induction cooktop, all new bathrooms, and new walls and fresh paint throughout. New siding and windows are scheduled for completion this spring, along with the final renovation of the walk-out level bathroom to complete the third full bath.

Additional features include a screened porch for seasonal enjoyment, a brand-new 3-bedroom mound septic system, and a rare combination of acreage, privacy, and private waterfront—offering a peaceful Bay Shore setting designed for year-round living.

Two parcels are still separate tax parcels. Top parcel could eventually be sold off by new owners.